Cuba 1899 & 1905 Issues: original & re-engraved differences

 

1905 Scott 237 10c brown "Cane Field"

Re-engraved

Into the Deep Blue

Bits and pieces of memory flood back when I look again at the original 1899 and re-engraved 1905 stamp issues of Cuba: There I was as a 12 year old in the living room of our old house, trying to make sense of the differences these stamps exhibited. I think I mostly succeeded, but not entirely, as I never would have had the 1905 5c blue "Ocean Liner", with the re-engraved secret mark - too expensive for my boyhood budget (Today CV $8).

So, with a tinge of nostalgia, and the realization, even now, that these issues can be confused, I thought a proper look at the differences would be in order.

As students of Cuban history know, the 1899 issue came into being while the U.S. had military rule and occupation of Cuba, due to the Spanish-American war in 1898.

There were five stamps for the 1899 issue (1c, 2c, 3c, 5c,10c), and four stamps for the 1905 re-engraved

issue (1c, 2c, 5c, 10c). Since I want to illustrate differences, the 1899 3c will not be discussed further.

One problem Scott presented to us collectors is that their illustration of the differences were in black & white until very recently, and particularly the "2c" illustration was confusing. Fortunately, my 2020 catalogue now shows the illustrations in color with better resolution.

So, let's take a closer look...

1899 Scott 227 1c yellow green 

"Statue of Columbus"; Original

The original 1c has a fairly obvious sign if you know where to look.  Also, the 1c's color was "yellow green", which might offer a clue compared to the 1c "green" or "light green" of the 1905 issue.

1899 Cuba Issue: Double-lined "C" (left) & "U" (right)

Wmk US-C (191C)

I should mention, for those familiar with the USA Wmk 191 (Double lined "USPS" in Capitals), that there was a special 191 variation watermark (191C) used on the 1899 Cuba issue: namely "US-C". 

1899 Scott 227 1c yellow green Close-up

Original: The ends of the "Centavo" tablet are square

Well, here is the difference that identifies the 1c original: Note that either end of the "Centavo" tablet is square.

1905 Scott 233 1c green 

"Statue of Columbus"; Re-engraved

OK, now the 1 centavo of 1905. Note the "green" color. Also, this issue is unwatermarked. Note also that both the 1899 & the 1905 issues are Perf 12.

1905 Scott 233 1c green Close-up

Re-engraved: The ends of the "Centavo" tablet are rounded

The close-up of the 1905 1c shows that either end of the "Centavo" tablet is rounded (or cut into top and bottom if you prefer).

1899 Scott 228 2c carmine "Royal Palms"

Original

The 2c is one of those stamps I clearly remember from my childhood. ;-) It can be found either as "carmine" (major number) or scarlet. 

1899 Scott 228 2c carmine Close-up

Original: Foliate ornaments inside "2" disk oval

The clue to identifying the 1899 2c is to look inside the oval surrounding the "2". There is a "9 o'clock" and a "3 o'clock" foliate ornament present inside the oval.

Cover 1899 Scott 228 2c carmine Original

Soldier's letter (Sperow): Co. F., with 10th U.S. Infantry based in Matanzas

Matanzas, Cuba 4-4-1900 to Boston, Mass

Backstamped Havana, Cuba 4-4-1900

Here is a soldier's letter posted 4-4-1900 from Cuba. Recall that the U.S. had occupation forces there after the 1898 Spanish-American war.

Cover: Matanzas, Cuba 4-4-1900 to Boston, Mass

Stamp: 1899 Scott 228 2c carmine 

Original: Foliate ornaments inside "2" disk oval

Sure enough, the stamp is the 1899 2c carmine with the foliate ornaments inside the "2" ovals.

1905 Scott 234b 2c carmine "Royal Palms"

Re-engraved

Let's look at the 1905 re-engraved 2c. Take a look inside the "2" ovals.

(BTW, I think the color here is minor number "carmine", rather than major number "rose". It turns out the carmine color has a lesser CV (<$1) than the rose color ($1+) The carmine color must be also more common?)

1905 Scott 234b 2c carmine Close-up

Re-engraved: No foliate ornaments inside "2" disk oval

A look inside the oval "2" shows no foliate ornaments.

Cover: 1905 Scott 234b 2c carmine Re-engraved

8-31-08 Caibarien, Santa Clara, Cuba to Decatur, Georgia via Havana

Arrived 9-4-08

I'm beginning to think that postal historians (those that like their stamps on covers) do not pay a lot of attention to the stamps themselves. The seller here listed the stamp as "228" - the 1899 2c stamp.

Cover: Caibarien, Santa Clara, Cuba 8-31-1908 to Decatur, Georgia

Stamp: 1905 Scott 234b  2c carmine 

Re-engraved: No foliate ornaments inside "2" disk oval

Do you see any foliate ornaments inside the oval 2s? No! This is clearly a 1905 2c issue, which is  appropriate for a 1908 cover.

1899 Scott 230 5c blue "Ocean Liner"

Original

The original 5c blue 1899 edition. 

1899 Scott 230 5c blue Close-up

Original: There are no right angle lines added 

in the upper corners of the "Cuba" tablet

For this stamp, the sign is subtle - there are no added right angle lines in the upper "Cuba" tablet.

1905 Scott 236 5c blue "Ocean Liner"

Re-engraved

The 1905 issue 5c blue is CV $40+/$8 (unused/used). I suspect this stamp is missing from many ordinary WW collections.

And the sign for the 1905 issue 5c is also subtle....

1905 Scott 236 5c blue Close-up

Re-engraved: There are right angle lines added 

in the upper corners of the "Cuba" tablet

Look carefully at the upper corners of the "Cuba" tablet: There are placed "right angle lines"...almost a secret sign!

1899 Scott 231 10c brown "Cane Field"

Original

Fortunately, the 1899 10c brown has a not so subtle sign...

1899 Scott 231 10c brown "Cane Field" Close-up

Original: Square ends either side of "Cuba" tablet

Look for square ends.

1905 Scott 237 10c brown "Cane Field"

Re-engraved

Now, the re-engraved 1905 10c brown....

1905 Scott 237 10c brown "Cane Field" Close-up

Re-engraved; Small "ball" added to the square ends

The square ends have a ball added. !!!

Ocean Liner Close-up

1899 Scott 5c blue

Out of the Blue

I hope you enjoyed the close examination of the differences between the 1899 and 1905 issues. Admittedly, most are fairly obvious if one knows where to look. !!

Comments appreciated!

Nevis - Bud's Big Blue

A selection of Medical Springs stamps

Bud's Big Blue

Bud's Observations

Jim suggested that world-wide collectors should acquire a few of Nevis’ famous Medicinal Springs stamps because of their unique design, even though they tend to be rather expensive (see Jim’s post here). So, to use a phrase common in my great grandmother’s time, I decided to “take the waters.” Not literally, of course, for I have no desire to swig hot mineral water or loll about in it regardless of any alleged curative benefits.

The stamps’ design tells a powerful story, though. A fainting, perhaps dying woman is supported by another while a third pours a therapeutic quaff. I hope it restored her vigor. Certainly, the stamps vigorously promote the spas. Scott lists 18 major numbers with this design.

The spas of Nevis were a 19^th century luxury attraction. And they still exist.

Nevis spa. Photo credit: www.tripadvisor.com

As a start, I bought five of Medicinal Springs stamps (shown below), all reasonably priced -- two of the one cent and three of the four cent variety. Sometime after making the purchases, however, I learned that the Nevis spring waters had been muddied by forgers. Even the 14 stamps of Nevis’ Queen Victoria design have been extensively forged. My Medicinal Springs examples might test positive for the forgery virus, as do many of those offered by on-line auctions.

For genuine vs forgery comparisons, see:  http://stampforgeries.com/forged-stamps-of-nevis/. The forgeries, however, make an interesting collection in their own right, including those forged as recently as Nevis’ 1984 automobile series. Serious forgery collectors will want to consult a 1910 book by Fred J. Melville -- The Postage Stamps of Nevis & How to Detect the Forged Stamps of Nevis. A digital reprint recently became available.

Used Nevis stamps often bear the “A09”, the British designation for Charlestown, the capital of Nevis. The “A09” was used on British stamps before the colony had stamps of their own inscribed “Nevis.” In the 1880s, Nevis created an overprinted bisect -- the one cent purple Queen Victoria was split in half to create two ½ cent stamps. Scott catalog provides major numbers for these two, one for the black overprint and one for the violet. An example of the black overprint is showing on the supplement page.

The Medicinal Spring design achieved restored vigor of a sort when, in 1903, Nevis began issuing stamps conjointly with St Kitts, a nearby Caribbean island. The redrawn vignettes show the scene more clearly than do the originals.

St. Kitts and Nevis, Scott #s 5, 35, 87, and 14

I suspect that many collectors are glad that only four spaces, out of a possible 32, need to be filled to complete the Big Blue Nevis page. To make it even easier, three of the four can be filled with any Nevis stamp.

Census: four in BB spaces, eight on supplement page.

Jim's Observations

Nevis (named originally by the Spanish as "Nuestra Senora de las Nieves" -Our Lady of the Snows), was actually settled by British settlers, who migrated from Saint Christopher, in 1628. The sugar cane grown on the island, with the help of imported African slaves, was highly profitable, even outproducing Jamaica in the 17th century. But an invasion by the French d'Iberville in 1704 decimated the sugar industry, and Nevis never really recovered.

In 1883, St. Christopher, Nevis, and Anguilla were linked under one "Presidency", with the headquarters on St. Christopher (St. Kitts). Naturally. Nevis was not pleased, as they had their own "Presidency" prior to this new administrative arrangement.

In 1778, the Bath Hotel was built to take advantage of the hot springs in the area. This, interestingly, was the first attempt at "tourism" in the Caribbean. The "Medicinal Spring" theme was also featured on the first issues of Nevis 1861-1876, some 19 stamps. 

Nevis Blog Post & BB Checklist

Page 1

1a

Supplements

Page 1

1a

Comments appreciated!

Cuba Alfonso XII 1882-88 Issues: Original; 1st retouch; 2nd retouch Differences

1882 Scott 101 2c lake "Alfonso XII"

Original State

Into the Deep Blue

Issued under Spanish Dominion, the typographed "Alfonso XII" stamps of Cuba 1882-1888 do not have a year date in their (Scott A17) design, as do the earlier 1880 & 1881 "Alfonso XII" issue stamps. But they have something more - "retouches" of their design found with certain stamp denominations.

These "retouches" are somewhat confusing, and I thought a blog post dedicated to a close look at them would be helpful for collectors of classical era Cuba. 

It doesn't help that the black & white (small) fuzzy illustrations for the differences in the Scott catalogue has only been recently upgraded (my 2020 Classic 1840-1940 Scott has it) to small (but better!) color illustrations. 

For background, my original Cuba post is here...

Cuba Blog Post & BB Checklist

I should mention that the Spanish Dominion "Alfonso XII" issues of the Philippines and Puerto Rico have similar "retouches", and so I will briefly cover those stamp examples as well.

1882 Issue: A closer look

100 Centavos = 1 Peso

1882 Scott 101b 2c rose "Alfonso XII"

Original State

The 1882 issue of six stamps (Scott 100-105) share the same medallion portrait of "Alfonso XII" as the

preceding 1880 (six stamps) and 1881 (six stamps) issues. But, as mentioned, the 1882 issue does not

have the year issue date (1880 or 1881) included as part of the design of the stamp. CV, overall, for the

1882 issue ranges from <$1 to $50.

Medallion 1882 2c Original State

"Alfonso XII"

As said,  the medallion portrait of "Alfonso XII" is the same for the 1880, 1881, and 1882 issues. This medallion portrait is called the "Original State". Let's take a look at some of the 1882 stamps to learn the characteristics of the "Original State" portrait....

1882 Scott 102 2 1/2c dark brown "Alfonso XII"

Original State

The 2 1/2c 1882 Scott 102 is "dark brown" for the major number. Color is one of the properties that distinguish this 1882 stamp. The 1883-86 Scott 122  2 1/2c is "olive bister", the 1883-86 Scott 124 2 1/2c is "violet", while the 1888 Scott 129 2 1/2c is "red brown". All of these (major number) stamps have the "Original State" portrait.

Medallion 1882 2 1/2c  Original State

"Alfonso XII"

So what are the characteristics of the "Original State"?

According to Scott: "The medallion is surrounded by a heavy line of color of nearly even thickness"

Comment: This is important as the 1st retouch & the 2nd retouch are decidedly not surrounded by a line of color of even thickness. 

1882 Scott 103 5c gray blue "Alfonso XII"

Original State

Another characteristic of the "Original State" type, according to Scott: "The heavy oval line of color surrounding the medallion touches the horizontal line above" - part the "Cuba" tablet. (Also the "Philippines" tablet and the "Puerto Rico" tablet respectively for those stamps.)

Comment: The 1st retouch & the 2nd retouch type stamps do not have the oval line of color touch the horizontal line above.

Also, the 5c gray blue for the 1882 issue is "original state", while the 1883-86 5c gray blue stamps are found as 1st retouch (Scott 125) and 2nd retouch (Scott 126). Therefore, for a 5c "gray blue" stamp, one will need to determine what type it is to determine what issue and Scott number it is.

1882 Scott 104 10c olive bister "Alfonso XII"

Original State

The last characteristic of the "Original State": "The opening of the hair above the temple is narrow and pointed"

Comment: Important! Neither 1st retouch or 2nd retouch have this sign as we shall see.

1882 Scott 104 10c olive bister on Cover

Folded Envelope, Havana, Cuba to Vera Cruz, Mexico 2-14-1882

As a change in pace, here is a cover from Cuba to Mexico in 1882. It has the 1882 issue 10c olive bister "Alfonso XII" stamp with the "original state" type. CV(cover) is $25.

1882 Scott 105 20c red brown "Alfonso XII"

Original State

Let's take a look at the "Original State" characteristics for the 1882 20c red brown..

Medallion 1882 20c  Original State

"Alfonso XII"

Medallion surrounded by oval thick line of color of more or less even thickness...Check.

Thick oval line at top attaches to horizontal line....Check.

Hair opening above temple narrow and pointed....Check.

1883-86 Issue: "Types of 1882" (seven major number stamps)

1883-86 Scott 121 1c green "Alfonso XII"

2nd retouch

We start off with a bang, as the 1883-86 issue 1c green shows a 2nd retouch. (The 1882 1c green stamp, on the other hand, is original state.)  BTW, the CV for the 1c green 2nd state is $40.

Medallion 1883-86 1c  2nd retouch

"Alfonso XII"

The "2nd retouch" shows a semi-circle opening at the hair temple, and the lock above the forehead is nearly straight, having only a slight wave.

And look at the colored line around the medallion oval: It is thinner except along the upper right. And the top of the colored oval line does not touch the horizontal line above. !! And notice, as the colored oval line is thinner, the white oval line is therefore broader.

1883-86 Scott 122 2 1/2c olive bister "Alfonso XII"

Original State

Bur not all of the 1883-86 issue stamps show 1st or 2nd retouch characteristics: the 2 1/2c olive bister is "original state".  Therefore, the Scott 122 is determined by the color ("olive bister"). (Recall that the 1882 2 1.2c is "dark brown", also "original state".)

1883-86 Scott 124 2 1/2c violet "Alfonso XII"

Original State

There was also a 2 1/2c "violet" (major number) stamp issued during the 1883-86 period in the original state. Of interest, there are two minor number color variations. The "red lilac" color has a similar CV as the major number color (CV <$1). But Scott 124 b 2 1/2c "ultramarine" is CV $125!

Medallion 1883-86 2 1/2c violet  Original State

"Alfonso XII"

Take a good look at the close-up as it shows clearly the "original state" characteristics: thick even oval color line which is attached to the horizontal line above, and the narrow hair line at the temple.

1883-86 Scott 126 5c gray blue "Alfonso XII"

2nd retouch

Contrast that with the 5c 2nd retouch stamp shown above. (Obviously, the "gray-blue" color here is faded.)

Medallion 1883-86 5c  2nd retouch

"Alfonso XII"

2nd retouch: a semi-circle opening at the hair temple; the lock above the forehead nearly straight; colored oval line thinner except upper right. 

1883-86 Scott 127 10c brown "Alfonso XII"

1st retouch

OK, our first example of a 1st retouch! The 1883-86 10c stamp is "brown" (major number), or "reddish brown (minor number). Both are 1st touch in the catalogue. Even if one is not aware of 1st touch characteristics, the brown or reddish brown colors will help with identification versus "olive bister" (1882-original state) or "blue" ( 1888-also 1st touch, but much different color).

Medallion 1883-86 10c brown 1st retouch

"Alfonso XII"

1st touch characteristics...

The temple hair wedge is neither narrow (original state) or semi-circular (2nd touch), but between. ;-)

The lock of hair above the forehead is a "wide V" shape and ends in a (soft) point.*

There is a faint white line below the lock of hair.*

(*Note: "Owing to wear of the plate, the shape of the lock of the hair and the width of the white line below can vary".)

And, found for both 1st touch and 2nd touch: the color oval line around the medallion is thin, except for the upper right. And the oval line does not touch the horizontal line above it. Comment: I find this feature useful to first separate out "Original State" from "1st/2nd touches".

1883-86 Scott 127b 10c reddish brown "Alfonso XII" on Cover

Cover, Havana, Cuba to Leeds, England 3-27-1884; Back cancelled 4-12-1884

Now this is an interesting story. The seller on the APS Stamp store website labeled the stamp as Cuba 1882 Scott 104. Clearly, he/she may have been a postal historian, but was not aware of the fine points of the 1882-88 "Alfonso XII" issues: specifically the "original", "1st touch", and "2nd touch" types. The stamp turns out to be a "1st touch" type, and it is a minor number color:  Scott 127b "reddish brown". CV (cover) is $42+, about twice what the seller thought it was worth. Yes, it pays to know something about stamp issues. !!

1883-86 Scott 128 20c olive bister "Alfonso XII"

Original State

The 1883-86 20c "Olive bister" is only found in the original state. The other 20c stamps (same A17 design) are also "original state", and separated by color (1882 "red brown", 1888 "brownish gray").

1888 Issue

1888 Scott 129 2 1/2c red brown "Alfonso XII"

Original State

The 1888 2 1/2c "red brown" (major number) is "original state" (above). But be aware that the 1888 Scott 129a 2 1/2c "pale brown" is found as a "1st retouch". !! The Scott 129a is the only 2 1/2c stamp of the A17 design that is found with a "1st retouch": the others (Scott 102, 102b, 122, 124, 124a, 124b, 129) are all "original state".

Note the "dark spot" plate flaw? on the cheek of this example. 

1888 Scott 130 10c blue "Alfonso XII"

1st retouch

Another "1st touch" example...

Medallion 1888 10c blue 1st retouch

"Alfonso XII"

The temple hair wedge is neither narrow (original state) or semi-circular (2nd touch), but between. 

The lock of hair above the forehead is a "wide V" shape and ends in a (soft) point.

There is a faint white line below the lock of hair.

And, found for both 1st touch and 2nd touch: the color oval line around the medallion is thin, except for the upper right. And the oval line does not touch the horizontal line above it.

I should mention that any difficulties I have with separating out the types is between 1st touch and 2nd touch types. (The "original state" is usually obvious.) It is a bit of a judgement call, although I am usually more confident then that. And, what really helps, is that often the catalogue only lists one type as a possibility. ;-)

1888 Scott 128 20c brownish gray "Alfonso XII"

Original State

And finally, the 1888 three stamp set ends with a 20c "brownish gray" original state. This stamp is determined by the color, compared to the other A17 1882-88 20c stamps - all of which are also original state.

Now, there are similar examples of "original state", "1st retouch", "2nd retouch" found with the Philippines and Puerto Rico. Let's take a look....

Philippines 1880-86 "Alfonso XII" Issue

Philippines 1882 Scott 78 2 4/8 c ultramarine "Alfonso XII"

Original State

The Philippines typographic 1880-86 "Alfonso XII" issue (thirteen stamps) shares the same "Medallion" design as the 1882-88 Cuba stamps.

But all of the stamps in the Philippines issue are "Original State", except for the 2 4/8 c ultramarine denomination, which can be found with Original State/1st retouch/2nd retouch types respectively (Scott 78, 79, 80). CV for these 2 4/8 ultramarine stamps is $1+, <$1, $4+ respectively.

The example above is "Original State", and has the narrow temple hair wedge, the more or less even thickness of the oval color line surrounding the medallion, and the oval line attached to the horizontal line above.

Philippines 1883 Scott 79 2 4/8 c ultramarine "Alfonso XII"

1st retouch

This is the "1st retouch" example (Scott 79), and shows an oval color line surrounding the medallion that is thinner, except the upper right portion. Close examination of the oval color line with the horizontal line above shows it is NOT attached. The opening of the temple hair wedge is wider (compared to the original state), and the lock of hair is shaped like a broad "V" that comes to a (soft) point. There is a faint white line below the lock of hair.

Philippines 1886 Scott 80 2 4/8 c ultramarine "Alfonso XII"

2nd retouch

The "2nd retouch" (above) shows the temple hair space to be very wide (almost 90 degrees), and the lock of hair is flatter and much less pointed. The color line oval around the medallion is thin and not attached to the horizontal line above. The white line on the forehead below the hair line appears broader.

Comment: The cancel mark, I believe, is fiscal. Although the signs here point to "2nd retouch", I am not absolutely certain. Scott does point out that the shape of the hair and the width of the white line can vary owing to wear of the plate.

Puerto Rico 1882-86 "Alfonso XII" Issue

Puerto Rico 1882 Scott 67 5c gray blue "Alfonso XII"

Original State

Likewise, Puerto Rico, with the 1882-86 "Alfonso XII" issue (twenty stamps), can show original state/ 1st retouch/2nd retouch types with the 5c gray blue (Scott 67-69, CV $1+-$5+).

Here, this stamp is "original state", with the narrow temple hair wedge, the even thickness of the oval color line, and the fact that the color line is attached to the horizontal line above.

Puerto Rico 1884 Scott 68 5c gray blue "Alfonso XII"

1st retouch

The "1st retouch" shows a wider temple hair wedge, and a broad "V" hair lock that comes to a (soft) point. Note the color line oval around the medallion is thin (except the upper right portion) and not attached to the horizontal line above. There is a quite thin faint white line below the hair line on the forehead.

Puerto Rico 1886 Scott 69 5c gray blue "Alfonso XII"

2nd retouch

The "2nd retouch" shows a semi-circle opening of the temple hair line (quite wide), and the lock of hair is flatter and less pointed. The color line oval around the medallion is thin (except for the upper right portion) and not attached to the horizontal line above. The white line on the forehead below the hair line appears broader.

1883-86 Scott 121 1c green "Alfonso XII"

2nd retouch

Out of the Blue

Well, I hope this exercise of reviewing the "Alfonso XII" original state/1st retouch/2nd retouch signs with specific examples for Cuba (mostly), the Philippines, and Puerto Rico has been helpful. I'm glad I did this post, as I am more confidant and sure now about the "types" differences, and how to tell one from another.  !!

Comments appreciated!