Big Blue 1840-1940

A is for Aden and Z is for Zanzabar

Wednesday, November 18, 2020

Cook Islands - a closer look

1902 Scott 30 1/2p green "Wrybill (Torea)"

Perf 11, Wmk 61

Into the Deep Blue
The Cook Islands (fifteen islands, but mainly Rarotonga) are a Dependency of New Zealand.

The original Blog Post and BB Checklist is here....

http://bigblue1840-1940.blogspot.com/2011/07/cook-islands-rarotonga.html

Here is a map, courtesy of the late Gerben van Gelder....

What the original blog post lacked was few pics/scans of the stamps themselves. So, now, let's take a closer look...

A Closer Look
12 Pence = 1 Shilling
20 Shillings = 1 Pound

1902 Scott 30 1/2p green "Wrybill"

Perf 11, Wmk 61

Between 1892-1919, there were really only three designs among the 44 Scott numbers, with the "Wrybill" accounting for twelve of them. The typographic "Wrybill" stamps can be found with various perfs, and Wmk 62, Wmk 61, and unwatermarked. These are New Zealand watermarks, and I show them with the New Zealand post, and down below.

Left Top: Wmk 6 "Large Star"

Right Top: Wmk 62 "N Z and Small Star Wide Apart"

Left Bottom: Wmk 63 "Double Lined N Z and Star"

Right Bottom: Wmk 61 "N Z and Star Close Together"

The "Wrybill" stamps have a CV from $3+ to $100+.

A pic of the Wrybill, with a bill that is bent sideways (hence the name), was shown by Bud for his blog post on the Cook Islands...

1919 Issue

New Zealand Stamps of 1909-19 Surcharged

In 1919, thirteen stamps of 1909-19 New Zealand were surcharged in deep blue or red for Rarotonga. The surcharge, which is in Polynesian, repeats the English denomination.

1919 Scott 49 1p carmine

Here is an up-close of the 1p carmine with the "tai pene" denomination.

1919 Scott 53 2 1/2p dull blue

Red Surcharge

In red, the Polynesian surcharge denomination is shown for this stamp. CV for the issue varies from <$1 to $3+ (unused).

1920 Scott 63 1 1/2p blue & black

"Capt. James Cook"

In 1920, an engraved six design six stamp issue for Rarotonga was released. Actually, any stamp printed or overprinted "Raratonga" could be used throughout the Cook Islands.

This stamp shows the ubiquitous explorer James Cook.

CV for the issue ranges from $2+ to $10.

1932 Scott 87 2 1/2p dark ultramarine

"View of Avarua Harbor"

An engraved unwatermarked seven stamp seven design issue was released in 1932. Note the "Cook Islands" labeling. This issue replaced the Aitutaki, Penrhyn, and Rarotonga specific issues.

CV is $3+ - $20+.

BTW, there are some inverted centers found, but are considered printers waste, except for the inverted 1p brown lake - black center (CV $9,000+).

1936 Scott 93 2p brown & black

"Double Canoe"

The 1936 issue (seven stamps) is the same design wise as the 1932 issue, but on Wmk 61 paper.

CV is <$1-$20+.

1935 Scott 100 6p dull orange & green

"R.M.S. Monowai"; Silver Jubilee Issue

For the Silver Jubilee of King George V, the Cook Islands eschewed the common design, and overprinted three stamps as Types (different colors) from the 1932 issue. CV is <$1-$7.

1940 Scott 115 3p on 1 1/2p violet & black

"Mt. Ikurangi behind Avaruna"

This 1940 stamp with the above design was only released surcharged.

Really lovely.

1944 Scott 122 1sh deep violet & black "George VI"

Types of 1932-38

In 1938, a three stamp, three design, high value (1sh, 2sh, 3sh) issue was released with Wmk 61. These stamps were reissued in 1944-46 as part of a 1932-38 "Types" issue. For the 1sh, 2sh, & 3sh denominations, the stamps are on Wmk 253 paper.

1949 Scott 133 2p carmine & brown

"Rev. John Williams, his ship Messenger of Peace,

and map of Rarotonga"

In 1949, an engraved ten stamp ten design multicolored historical pictorial issue was published.

Very nice!

The 2p carmine & brown displays a Rarotonga map, and John Williams, first missionary in Rarotonga -1823.

1936 Scott 93 2p brown & black

"Double Canoe"

Out of the Blue
Early classical Cook Islands stamps - especially the engraved varieties - are spectacular!

Comments appreciated!

Thursday, November 12, 2020

"Classic Stamp Forgeries" - a new and fantastic stamp forgery blog site for WW classical era collectors

Armenia 1921 Scott 283 50r red "Armenian Soldier"

Soviet Socialist Republic

"Counterfeits Exist": Ron's Site will show you the genuine & counterfeit differences

Into the Deep Blue

I've got really good news for those that are frustrated with stamp forgery concerns for the 1840-1940 WW classical era: a new blog site with detailed genuine/forgery information.

Classical Stamp Forgeries

https://stampforgeries.blogspot.com/

This resource is the brainchild of Ron (SForgeCa), and it is much more than a passive genuine/forgery comparison. Ron combs the obscure philatelic literature and journals, and then synthesizes the information and stamp scan images into a coherent and original presentation with detailed and specific genuine/forgery signs.

The information is so outstanding that I told Ron I would gladly pay for it!

If you click on the site, you will note that presently he has information about Armenian issues. But he tells me that he has some 150 posts to be added, so we should check back often. !!

Thursday, November 5, 2020

Mexico - Bud's Big Blue

Aztec courier (1)

Bud's Big Blue
Bud's Observations

Mexico bears an enduring reputation, at least partly deserved, for poor stamp designs. The earlier issues particularly merit this dishonor. Forgers’ slew of fakes and counterfeits are usually uglier than the legitimate.

The Hidalgo issue of 1872, for instance, receives heaps of scorn. Even Wikipedia’s article on Mexico’s stamps disdains it (2). The designs of earlier Hidalgo series, there are four of them, fare somewhat better (see page 1 below). Miguel Hidalgo y Costilla, a progressive priest, launched the struggle that ended Spain’s colonial rule of Mexico (1810-21). Of the 241 major numbers that Scott Catalog assigns to Mexico stamps prior to 1895, half (120) bear Hidalgo’s likeness.

Hidalgo, Scott #s 81-83, 86

As an anti-theft measure, district names, dates, and invoice numbers were commonly affixed on the Hidalgo stamps and other early issues (1856-1883) -- a popular collecting focus for specialists. The wide variety of cancellations also attracts interest.

Designs improved greatly beginning in 1895 with the mulitas (little mules) issue. These stamps show the ways Mexican mail was transported and delivered -- a rural letter carrier wearing a sombrero, pack mules (the mulitas) with a rider, a stage coach, and a mail train with a small sail boat (in left background).

Scott #s 243 // 289

The mulita series has many variations. Scott Catalog lists 50 major numbers and 44 subordinates for the six designs, plus an assortment of imperfs and other peculiarities. Although indistinct on many examples, I’m particularly fond of the rural mail carrier, enlarged below.

Scott #244, orange brown

1895 Scott 247 5c ultramarine
"Statue of Cuauhtemoc"

Although not apparent as first glance, the connection between postal delivery and the blue 5c mulita (#247 et al.) harks back to the Aztec era. Up until the Spanish conquest (1519–21), the Aztec Empire was connected by an elaborate network of postal runners. The blue monument on the 5c represents Cuauhtemoc (d. ca. 1525), the last Aztec ruler. Mexico’s postal service follows in the pathways of the Aztec runners. Some current patrons complain that the runners probably delivered more quickly than the postal service.

Scott #c203, Aztec courier competing favorably, red orange

Mexico’s best early 20^th century stamp designs draw their subject matter from two main sources: Spanish colonial architecture and indigenous Mexican American culture, both ancient and contemporary. As for the rest: scenic and historical designs are too cluttered, overprints are too pervasive, politicians’ faces are, well, just politicians’ faces.

Am I an art critic? Hardly! My whims about stamp designs come merely from my own likes and gripes. As a certified curmudgeon, I have a large collection of such. So, clearly, my biases won’t decide the merits of any particular stamp design, Mexican or otherwise. But…

Weakness of stamp design ordinarily crops up in countries with massive turmoil, as was the case of Mexico in the early 20^th century. On the page scans shown below, on can trace the havoc wreaked by the Mexican civil war, world wars, earthquakes, terrorists, economic depression, and the forced repatriation of Mexicans in the 1930s by the USA.

Nevertheless with these disclosures posted and readers forewarned, here are some late classical era Mexican stamps that I really like.

Scott #s o99, 628, o223, 648

Vera Cruz Lighthouse, Mexico City Post Office, Palace of Fine Arts,

Communications Building (now the National Art Museum)

Spanish colonial architecture, with its luscious baroque/rococo garnishes, continued to thrive well into Mexico’s 20^th century when it successfully merged with neo-classical and Art Nouveau styles. The stamps capture the power of these architectural triumphs without becoming too cluttered -- a philatelic feat worth noticing. Even with “official” overprints (of which Mexico has many, see supplement pages), the buildings’ exterior beauty remains in clear view.

The interiors of the above four buildings are even more spectacular. Travelers have posted many pictures of them on the internet.

Scott #s c108-10

Michoacan University of Saint Nicholas of Hidalgo, Morelia

Brimming with unspoiled colonial architecture, the entire city of Morelia is now a UNESCO World Heritage site. UNESCO has designated 35 World Heritage sites in Mexico, most of which feature architecture. The United States, by comparison, has 24 sites, very few of which feature architecture. Brazil has 22 sites; Argentina has 11. I’m not, apparently, the only one who likes Mexican architecture.

Scott #c121

Temple dedicated to Our Lady of Guadalupe, Guadalajara, 1781

Architecture, a major source of Mexico’s national pride, adorns more Mexican classical era stamps than it does for any other country -- not a surprise, because it’s lively and continues to evolve. Its magnificence inspires hope during troubled times. In the early 20^th century its exuberance shaped domestic and public architecture from Kansas to California.

Indigenous Mexican American culture, the other inspiration for Mexican stamp designs that I particularly like, does not come to full philatelic blossom until after 1950. However, traces of it can be found in the classical era. For example, #c73 and #e5-6, although rather generic, pick up the motif.

The 1934 Pro-Universidad issue, with ten vignettes of native Mexican life, provides the best examples. Themes include archery, pottery making, the arts, and worship. The high values of this set have become extremely expensive. Even the 20c to 50c denominations have rather high CVs. I’m not, apparently, the only one who likes them. My collection goes up to one peso, all with cancels. The one peso, depicting a craftsman, is shown below and again in the supplement pages, while the lesser seven values are in normal BB-provided spaces.

Scott #s c73, 704, e6

Mexico has handsome postal eagles, too.

Certification, circa 1930, rouletted and cancelled

Census: 369 in BB spaces, nine tip ins, 514 on supplement pages (plus another 100 or more added after scans were made). The “un real” Guadalajara provisional stamp in Supplement section -page 14 is not authentic.

(1) Paynani.com.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Postage_stamps_and_postal_history_of_Mexico

Jim's Observations
Mexico and it's history, both real and philatelic, is very complex, to say the least. Arguably, it's stamps show the most philatelic twists of any Latin American country.

Bud has done brilliant work here with the great discussion (above) and the 28 pages shown of Mexico's stamps. Enjoy!

Mexico Blog Post & BB Checklist

Page 1